Health care differs from nation to nation,
sometimes substantially depending upon the level of economic development and
the political system in place. Health care systems, on the global scale, are
best defined via the World Health Organization's definition: "A health
system consists of all organizations, people and actions whose primary intent
is to promote, restore or maintain health. This includes efforts to influence
determinants of health as well as more direct health-improving activities. A
health system is therefore more than the pyramid of publicly owned facilities
that deliver personal health services. “This definition is important when
observing international health care systems, as it captures both developed and
developing nations within this context.
Comparisons between healthcare in developing and developed nations:
Developed Nations
The World Health Organization has
been actively measuring a variety of performance indicators to determine an
overall ranking system for health care on a global scale. While this has seen
some objections, primarily due to the selection of attributes which weigh into
this ranking, it is designed to measure critical success factors which are
easily comparably across borders (apples to apples). These measured attributes
include health of the population, fair financial contributions, and
responsiveness of the system, preventable deaths, affordability and a range of
other considerations.
Let us explore
further through an example of health care in German (though not all European
countries are the same). Germany has consistently demonstrated reductions in
cost of health care per capita relative to GDP growth. German health care is
regulated by the Federal Joint Commission, a public health organization which
leverages governmental health reform bills to generate new regulations. This
system also includes a total of 85% of the population on the government offered
standardized health care plan, which covers a variety of health care needs
across the board. The remaining 15% of the population has opted for private
health insurance options, which provide unique niche benefits for specific groups.
This system has been highly effective and affordable in providing health care
to German citizens.
Developing Nations
The countries
who are going through the initial levels of industrial development along with
low per capita income are known as Developing Countries. These countries come
under the category of third world countries. They are also known as lower
developed countries.
Developing
Countries depend upon the Developed Countries, to support them in establishing
industries across the country. The country has a low Human Development Index
(HDI) i.e. the country does not enjoy healthy and safe environment to live, low
Gross Domestic Product, high illiteracy rate, poor educational, transportation,
communication and medical facilities, unsustainable government debt, unequal
distribution of income, high death rate and birth rate, malnutrition both to
mother and infant which case high infant mortality rate, poor living
conditions, high level of unemployment and poverty.
The following
are the names of some developing countries: China, Colombia, India, Kenya,
Malaysia, Singapore, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Turkey, U.A.E.
With fewer
resources, developing nations struggle to compete provide the same access to
health care as do developed nations.
China is an
interesting case study. China has a great deal of variance in quality and
accessibility, with hospital wait times for the poor (depending on severity)
taking many hours (sometimes days) compared to the rich, who are admitted
immediately. Transitioning towards a system that provides care to the rich and
the poor alike is the primary challenge in these developing regions.
Key Differences between Developed and
Developing Countries
The following
are the major differences between developed countries and developing countries
- The countries which are independent and
prosperous are known as Developed Countries. The countries which are
facing the beginning of industrialization are called Developing Countries.
- Developed Countries have a high per
capita income and GDP as compared to Developing Countries.
- In Developed Countries the literacy
rate is high, but in Developing Countries illiteracy rate is high.
- Developed Countries have good
infrastructure and a better environment in terms of health and safety,
which are absent in Developing Countries.
- Developed Countries generate revenue
from the service sector. Conversely, Developing Countries generate revenue
from the industrial sector.
- In developed countries the standard of
living of people is high which is in contrast to developing countries.
- Resources are effectively and
efficiently utilized in developed countries. On the other hand, proper
utilization of resources is not done in developing countries.
- In developed countries the birth rate
and death rate are low, whereas in developing countries both the rates are
high.
Challenges faced by developing nations to
provide adequate healthcare..
Many
developing countries also strive to provide universal health care. However,
most struggle to do so, due to lack of sufficient resources, or inappropriate
use of existing funds. Health inequality, therefore, is quite common.
Poverty is a major problem. In some
developing countries health facilities have improved considerably, creating a
health divide where those who can afford it can receive good quality care.
Health gaps typically mirror equality gaps. For the enormous numbers of people
without access to health, there is a terrible paradox: poverty exacerbates poor
health while poor health makes it harder to get out of poverty.
Corruption is an ever-present problem
(sometimes in wealthy countries too). Corruption not only makes the problem
worse, but some policies have encouraged corruption, too, as has the lack of
health resources.
Another issue
that plagues some poor countries is “brain drain” whereby the poor countries
educate some of their population to key jobs such as in medical areas and other
professions only to find that some rich countries try to attract them away.
In many poorer
countries, the number of health workers
such as doctors and nurses in proportion to the population can be small and
in many rural settings, it can be very difficult for people to access services.
The issue of user payment at point of use
is perhaps more important in poorer countries than the wealthier ones. In
wealthy ones, other than the US, universal health care works such that even
where people have to pay at point of use, in many cases it is affordable.
Around the
world, however, the problem can be worse as the WHO notes:
“Most of the world’s health-care systems
continue to rely on the most inequitable method for financing health-care
services: out-of-pocket payments by the sick or their families at the point of
service. For 5.6 billion people in low- and middle-income countries, over half
of all health-care expenditure is through out-of-pocket payments. This deprives
many families of needed care because they cannot afford it. Also, more than 100
million people around the world are pushed into poverty each year because of
catastrophic health-care expenditures. There is a wealth of evidence
demonstrating that financial protection is better, and catastrophic expenditure
less frequent, in those countries in which there is more prepayment for health
care and less out-of-pocket payment. Conversely, catastrophic expenditure is
more frequent when health care has to be paid for out-of-pocket at the point of
service.
WHO World Report 2008,”
In developing
countries, especially the poorest ones, a large portion of health funded is
dependent upon external or foreign aid. However, some spending programs may
divert from general needs to specific needs, such as building hospitals (as
opposed to strengthening primary care), or funding for specific diseases (which
is usually treatment based with less visible effort on preventative care), etc.
Conclusion
There is a big
difference between Developed Countries and Developing Countries as the
developed countries are self-contained and flourished while the developing
countries are emerging as a developed country. Developing Countries are the one
who experience the phase of development for the first time. If we talk about
developed countries, they are post-industrial economies and due to this reason
the maximum part of their revenue comes from the service sector.
Developed
Countries are having a high Human Development Index as compared to Developing
Countries. The former has established itself in all fronts and made itself
sovereign by its efforts while the latter is still struggling to achieve the
same.